ブリテンの議会ジャーナリズムは討論をどう再構成したか

1740年代初頭の『ジェントルマンズ・マガジン』と『ロンドン・マガジン』

苅谷千尋
kariyach@staff.kanazawa-u.ac.jp

金沢大学

November 7, 2026

ブリテンの議会ジャーナリズムは討論をどう再構成したか

目次

  • はじめに
  • 先行研究
  • 議会報道の方針と当時の論争
  • 両誌に共通する議会討論
  • 各誌が独自に報じた議会討論
  • 結び

レジュメ・資料（図）

  • 印刷してお配りしているものはレジュメのみです。資料（図）が必要な方はQRコードから入手下さい
  • 量的テキスト分析に興味がある方はRコード（github）を参照下さい

Political Vocabulary in Speeches for and against Standing Armies

Dictionary: Political Vocabulary

  • constitution_and_law: constitution; just; justice; right; libert; free; freedom; law; laws; lawful; legal; duty; duties; obligation; virtue; precedent; unprecedent; practice; practis; usage; custom; customary; ancient; antient; establish; established; maxim; immemorial; inherit; history; histories; successor*
  • parliament_and_procedure: parliament; senate; house; address; impeach; attainder; motion; question; procedure; proceeding; petition
  • crown_ministry_party: king; kings; emperor; crown; throne; majesty; minist; administration; court; courts; party; parties; faction; whig*; tory; tories; “landed interest”; “moneyed interest”
  • people_and_public_good: people; nation; countr; public; publick; publicly; common; commonwealth; welfare; prosper; securit; safety; patriot*
  • foreign_affairs: france; spain; austria; vienna; blefuscu; allemannu; treaty; treaties; alliance; war; wars; peace; enem; europ; foreign; negotiat; negociat
  • finance_and_commerce: trade; traffick; commerc; merchant; manufactur; revenue; tax; excise; debt; money; treasur; financ; credit*; customs

Rhetorical Vocabulary in Speeches for and against Standing Armies

Dictionary: Rhetorical Vocabulary

  • argumentation: persua; convinc; argument; proof; evidence*; prove; proves; proved; proven; proving; fact; facts
  • reasoning: reason; reasons; reasoning
  • rhetorical_critique: sophist; sophism; fallac; evasi; subterfuge; artifice; artifices; cunning; crafty; insinuat; false; untru; misrepresent; pretence; pretext*; groundless; imaginary; vain; vainly
  • rhetorical_expression: rhetoric; declamation; eloquen; ornament

Terms by Keyness: GM Speeches on Standing Armies

Terms by Keyness: LM Speeches on Standing Armies

Political Vocabulary in Speeches for and against Remove of Walpole

Dictionary: Political Vocabulary

  • constitution_and_law: constitution; just; justice; right; libert; free; freedom; law; laws; lawful; legal; duty; duties; obligation; virtue; precedent; unprecedent; practice; practis; usage; custom; customary; ancient; antient; establish; established; maxim; immemorial; inherit; history; histories; successor*
  • parliament_and_procedure: parliament; senate; house; address; impeach; attainder; motion; question; procedure; proceeding; petition
  • crown_ministry_party: king; kings; emperor; crown; throne; majesty; minist; administration; court; courts; party; parties; faction; whig*; tory; tories; “landed interest”; “moneyed interest”
  • people_and_public_good: people; nation; countr; public; publick; publicly; common; commonwealth; welfare; prosper; securit; safety; patriot*
  • foreign_affairs: france; spain; austria; vienna; blefuscu; allemannu; treaty; treaties; alliance; war; wars; peace; enem; europ; foreign; negotiat; negociat
  • finance_and_commerce: trade; traffick; commerc; merchant; manufactur; revenue; tax; excise; debt; money; treasur; financ; credit*; customs

Rhetorical Vocabulary in Speeches for and against Remove of Walpole

Dictionary: Rhetorical Vocabulary

  • argumentation: persua; convinc; argument; proof; evidence*; prove; proves; proved; proven; proving; fact; facts
  • reasoning: reason; reasons; reasoning
  • rhetorical_critique: sophist; sophism; fallac; evasi; subterfuge; artifice; artifices; cunning; crafty; insinuat; false; untru; misrepresent; pretence; pretext*; groundless; imaginary; vain; vainly
  • rhetorical_expression: rhetoric; declamation; eloquen; ornament

Terms by Keyness: GM Speeches on Remove of Walpole

Terms by Keyness: LM Speeches on Remove of Walpole